Why is El apostol back in the list? For a site dedicated to checking movies, It makes no sense to have lost films included :o( Put the movie back in the description.
There are a lot of good films on here, and indeed this is a good list, but I can't understand why iCM has added another list which cannot be completed due to the inclusion of a lost film. To me, that's really frustrating, to have an "official" check be uncheckable.
Also, I too notice the odd choice of that particular version of Alice in Wonderland.
Please remove El apostol and all other lost films from official lists. A list that is literally impossible to complete is counterproductive to the competitive purpose of this whole excellent website.
I watched Dallas Bower's Alice in Wonderland 2 days ago and I liked it more than the Disney film (although I hated the Disney film so that doesn't say much).
I don't have the book so I can't look at what he wrote, but if I'm not mistaken it was the first American stop-motion feature film, so that might be why he included it.
Edit: It's French according to Wikipedia and American according to IMDb.
Thanks for pointing that out. It seems like a strange choice, so maybe I should check the book to make sure that WorldCat didn't make a mistake (I think my public library has a copy of it).
Edit: I checked the book and WorldCat is correct. It is the Dallas Bower film.
Add your comment
Comments 1 - 15 of 18
iCheckMovies
We've removed the lost film for now, until we have a better system for lost movies!gulliver
Why is El apostol back in the list? For a site dedicated to checking movies, It makes no sense to have lost films included :o( Put the movie back in the description.PaleoSteno
El Apostol was added back on, was there a version of the film found somewhere?mjf314
@Timvv: El apóstol is lost.Jumping Elephant
There are a lot of good films on here, and indeed this is a good list, but I can't understand why iCM has added another list which cannot be completed due to the inclusion of a lost film. To me, that's really frustrating, to have an "official" check be uncheckable.Also, I too notice the odd choice of that particular version of Alice in Wonderland.
PaleoSteno
El Apostol still hasn't been re-removed. I don't know why it was added back on in the first place.estebanarciga13
El Apostol hasn't been removed. it's a lost filmkongs_speech
Please remove El apostol and all other lost films from official lists. A list that is literally impossible to complete is counterproductive to the competitive purpose of this whole excellent website.PaleoSteno
Oh good! They removed El Apostol and added Belladonna of Sadness!! Now this list can actually be completed.boomdiddly
Just a spelling fix, the intro blurb should read "entries" instead of "entires".greenhorg
44 of these films are on the other top 100 animation list.http://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/top+100+animated+features+of+all+time/
Timvv
@jumping elephant:Which film is lost? I'd like to know.
mjf314
I watched Dallas Bower's Alice in Wonderland 2 days ago and I liked it more than the Disney film (although I hated the Disney film so that doesn't say much).I don't have the book so I can't look at what he wrote, but if I'm not mistaken it was the first American stop-motion feature film, so that might be why he included it.
Edit: It's French according to Wikipedia and American according to IMDb.
mjf314
Thanks for pointing that out. It seems like a strange choice, so maybe I should check the book to make sure that WorldCat didn't make a mistake (I think my public library has a copy of it).Edit: I checked the book and WorldCat is correct. It is the Dallas Bower film.
frbrown
I haven't seen the book, but according to the link in The Spreadsheet (http://www.worldcat.org/title/100-animated-feature-films/oclc/656775568), "Alice in Wonderland" is not the Disney version, but this obscurity:http://www.icheckmovies.com/movies/alice+in+wonderland-1949/
Showing items 1 – 15 of 18