Be Tartib ya Bedoun-e Tartib (1995)'s comments

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

Emiam

3/10
OK, but boring and not very innovative (what does it do on a top list? Seems to be for politicians to take a stand), and eh... PeacefulAnarchy, there's no subs in this clip! What r u talking about??

Thanks, Thorkell, for the text tip! (Y)

8 years 6 months ago

Armoreska

Just in case, I upped that sub on opensubtitles

11 years 1 month ago

Rohit

This film should be a part of the school syllabus. Effective immediately in countries like India.

11 years 9 months ago

sha1tan

Finally found it:
http://mooweex.com/orderly-or-disorderly/

11 years 9 months ago

Thorkell

I really want to see this film!

11 years 10 months ago

monty

Where can one see this?

13 years 7 months ago

assilem23

Who knew Kiarostami could do comedy? I was laughing right through this one!

9 years 7 months ago

Thorkell

Great find! This text from IMDb helps:

A school scene. Class has ended. Students walk down the stairs in an orderly fashion. Good. Now rewind. Class has ended. Students walk down the stairs in a disorderly fashion. Bad.

The students make their way to a central court for their classroom break. A single water dispenser is at the center. Some students gather to drink. In orderly fashion it takes them a minute and ten seconds to satisfy their thirst. Rewind. In disorderly fashion it takes them three minutes and the dispenser is trashed in the confusion.

The point? Orderly behavior is efficient.

The dualist approach is now applied to pedestrians crossing a street. Orderly requires waiting for the green light. Disorderly means dodging cars and forcing cars to brake.

Next, cars approach a narrow tunnel. They bunch up at the entrance in disorderly fashion. If simple rules of orderly merging are obeyed by drivers, the cars line up quickly to enter the tunnel.

A major street intersection. Every car is trying to cross the intersection at the same time in all directions. Fender benders are avoided by centimeters. Turbulent flow is inefficient. Now Kiarostami tries to set the orderly version. A policeman is called in to put some order. But can he succeed in a city where cars are handled by disorderly drivers? Hey, what's that? A pedestrian just entered the frame disorderly running across the moving traffic. I guess it is hopeless in Iran.

11 years 9 months ago

PeacefulAnarchy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hi4j5luBx3Q youtube with subs

10 years 7 months ago