This movie was funny when it was made, but that does not mean it is right now, this movie is not funnier than 99% of today's comedies, this is the favourite movie of Emma Stone
3.5/5
I think it is the brilliance of Chaplin making this movie work. It is based on such a simple idea, so simple that it is essential. And sharing that experience with us is not that simple! I don't think the ending is cute, or lovely, but it is brilliant, it doesn't give an answer for the dilemma and therefore gives it to us. Would we love Chaplin if we see him as he really is?
I'm spoiled with today's comedies, so I didn't find this HILARIOUS. However, the whole film is packed with lightly comical scenes. It's still enjoyable to watch. To me, it's a good sign when the movie feels shorter than it actually is. This was one of those films.
I'm going to be the lone voice of dissent here, and say that although the final scene was very well done and emotional, I found the rest of the movie that it depends on to be contrived and illogical. The millionaire's soberness seeming to cause amnesia, thieves just happening to be hiding in the house when the tramp is given money, etc.
It might be OK if I found Chaplin's slapstick antics funny, but I don't.
City Lights is simply put one of the best movies out there. Every scene is classic and had a huge impact on the history of film-making. Current Studio heads should be made to watch these classic movies and instead of shallow unfunny films, might actually put a little heart into it.
Add your comment
Comments 1 - 15 of 33
Joker of Gotham
This movie was funny when it was made, but that does not mean it is right now, this movie is not funnier than 99% of today's comedies, this is the favourite movie of Emma Stone3.5/5
I-M-Pulsive
Too old for my likings. Watch it at 2times speed. And still didn't like it.Astrain42
(removed by mod: please post in English)Lumen
I think it is the brilliance of Chaplin making this movie work. It is based on such a simple idea, so simple that it is essential. And sharing that experience with us is not that simple! I don't think the ending is cute, or lovely, but it is brilliant, it doesn't give an answer for the dilemma and therefore gives it to us. Would we love Chaplin if we see him as he really is?briafly27
I'm spoiled with today's comedies, so I didn't find this HILARIOUS. However, the whole film is packed with lightly comical scenes. It's still enjoyable to watch. To me, it's a good sign when the movie feels shorter than it actually is. This was one of those films.thestaulker
You'll see :DPaulorsadv
Over sweet than Gold Rush, but brilliant.ChrisReynolds
I'm going to be the lone voice of dissent here, and say that although the final scene was very well done and emotional, I found the rest of the movie that it depends on to be contrived and illogical. The millionaire's soberness seeming to cause amnesia, thieves just happening to be hiding in the house when the tramp is given money, etc.It might be OK if I found Chaplin's slapstick antics funny, but I don't.
coral_ck
Chaplin is just so awesome! what a beautiful movie.seithscott
City Lights is simply put one of the best movies out there. Every scene is classic and had a huge impact on the history of film-making. Current Studio heads should be made to watch these classic movies and instead of shallow unfunny films, might actually put a little heart into it.Sir_Byzantium
The ending is one of the best movie endings I've ever seen.George Bailey
Actually made me laugh to tears!!Samdurden
''Yes! I can see now''kraantje
What a great romantic ending :)krisflushednemo
Very charmingShowing items 1 – 15 of 33