How Green Was My Valley (1941)'s comments

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

TimHeaney

Saccharine perhaps - terrible, inert and plodding definitely not. Melodramatic but in a positive sense. I quickly grew to care about these people and found this tearjerker far suprior to its modern equivelents.

14 years ago

inhonoredglory

What a beautiful film celebrating beautiful people, beautiful on the inside, of course - their strength of character and sense of family and duty. A meaningful film that aims at your heart and wins over your soul.

12 years 8 months ago

Timbo

This is a beautiful film. It's one of my favorites!

13 years 4 months ago

nbats

https://youtu.be/6mBkd-Au4IY

4 years ago

maruf_ur

@Zuma I didn’t like the anti-education message either but the message couldn’t ruin the movie at all. As a movie it was great.

9 years 9 months ago

Zuma

Wonderful cinematography ruined by the anti-education message and close-minded "values".

11 years 2 months ago

My name long game

What a movie... i think we can't find any families like these in this time

13 years ago

Gershwin

I'm afraid I agree with filmcave. This movie is way too melodramatic. It's also disgustingly moralistic, with its very conservative view on social issues.

12 years 7 months ago

filmcave

This is frankly, terrible. Saccharine, cloying, inert and plodding. It's what people who refuse to watch "old movies" fear that they are. A dreadful, painful watch. The sets are brilliant and the direction sound, but this is a worthless film.

14 years 1 month ago

Ebbywebby

So. Much. Singing.

3 years 9 months ago