The Lady Vanishes (1938)'s comments

Do you want to let us know what you think? Just login, after which you will be redirected back here and you can leave your comments.

Lemonball679

Excellent! The balance of mystery and humour are pitch perfect and never throw each other off course. Consistently gripping and enjoyable from the master of suspense. The pre-war British reserve and patriotism in the film may seem dated but its both endearing and humourous, and only enhanced my enjoyment. The film has aged but like a fine wine it has only got better!

11 years 9 months ago

Forrester

Another excellent Hitchcock movie. The Lady Vanishes is a fast-paced film with a great mix of comedy, suspense, mystery and romance. I really enjoyed this!

12 years 4 months ago

AJWH

Wonderfull film! one of my favorites by Hitchcock

Just one question however: What happens to the soldier who returns to his senses and finds a gun after being kicked in the head. He has the brits and the girls at gunpoint yet the situation is never resolved.

9 years 1 month ago

Flops

Only the third Hitchcock feature I've gotten around to after Rear Window and North by Northwest. I love the sarcasm Hitchcock's protagonists like to use. The Lady Vanishes employs much more humor than I was expecting and I was glad for it. This was a top quality film. It's hard to believe it is almost 3 times older than me. I'm going to watch more Hitchcock soon for sure.

11 years 9 months ago

Ivan0716

Perfect blend of humour and suspense.

13 years 10 months ago

Siskoid

Hitchcock's last British film before moving to Hollywood is The Lady Vanishes, an entertainingly BRITISH comedy of a thriller that has a lot of fun spoofing stiff upper lip types, in addition to the comedy inherent to the cramped Alpine hotel setting, and then the equally cramped train bound from a fictional Eastern European country to Britain. At some point, the thriller takes over and the laughs because more rare, but it's a smooth enough transition that you may not notice before it's too late. The mystery, involving a kind old woman who disappears from a moving train (and apparently from other people's memories!), is an interesting one for our heroine (and her annoying hotel room neighbor) to solve, reminiscent of Murder on the Orient Express, in its way, but with much loopier action. Hitchcock's humor would get darker in his more famous films, but The Lady Vanishes shows he was able to bend it to sweeter, less nasty amusements.

5 years 6 months ago

Robbimich

My 15th Hitchcock film to date and definitely in the middle range. Started out pretty good and interesting, liked the plot and the idea but the second half turned out to be rather dull and the last 30 minutes were really disappointing.

It was actually more of a comedy than a thriller, Hitch should have tried out a real comedy, I'm sure he would have nailed it.

I liked the two leading actors, they had good chemistry and I enjoyed their performance.

10 years 5 months ago

Filmsthemostbeautifulart

This was one of Hitchcock's last British movies and certainly one of his best. The Lady Vanishes is both thrilling and comic at the same time, a rare genre which only directors like Kubrick and Hitchcock himself have so far used to make a perfect cinematic experience. With it's memorable punchlines, witty direction and a thrilling plot, The Lady Vanishes manages to remain one of the best black and white movies to date...

5/5

11 years 8 months ago

DisneyStitch

An early Hitchcock classic. The director of suspense wasn't exactly at the beginning of his career here but certainly laying the foundation stones that would support his later fame and penchant for making fantastic films. The Lady Vanishes is a tight psychological thriller that doesn't waste any of its runtime. The buildup at the hotel is masterfully crafted and all the characters really pop. Old Hitch knows how to craft a gaggle of characters that are far from one-dimensional and the script really works. He really excels at how to make a character feel like they're losing their mind and include the audience along in the same boat.

1 year 9 months ago

SpacePauls

Why would a merry-go-round even be able to go that fast?

5 years 2 months ago

CinemaDump

Alfred Hitchcock found himself in a pretty interesting spot before having made The Lady Vanishes. He needed a film to fulfill a contract he had with producer Edward Black, who then offered him a project by the name of The Lost Lady which was based off of a book called The Wheel Spins by Ethel Lina White. This would later become The Lady Vanishes and had previously been a failed production. Roy William Neill had begun filming it in Yugoslavia but once officials found out that they were portrayed in a negative light, the team was kicked out of the country. Hitchcock was smart to set to set TLV in a fictional location. After all, everyone was all tense due to the brewing of a World War.

At the same time, the call of the United States was coming strong across the Atlantic. Alfred Hitchcock was adored stateside and Hollywood wanted him to be making movies for them. Beginning in 1939, producer David O. Selznick successfully signed Hitchcock to a seven-year agreement, ensuring his talents would remain in the US. This was following the release of The Lady Vanishes which ended up being a huge success financially and critically. The rest is history.

Synopsis

Iris Henderson (Margaret Lockwood) arrives with her two friends at the Gasthof Petrus inn located in Bandrika (fictional as I said). That night she gets disturbed by some noise coming from upstairs. A gentleman by the name of Gilbert (Michael Redgrave) is found to be the noisemaker and he finds even more ways to antagonize Iris. The next day on her departure, she gets hit on the head by a planter. Luckily a friend from the night before, Miss Froy (Dame May Whitty), insists she will take care of her during the ride. After a nap on the train, Miss Froy has apparently vanished without a trace.

Review

To me what sticks out as very strange about The Lady Vanishes which is clearly a mystery/thriller, is that it's also a comedy. The marriage of genres doesn't seem like something that would work at first glance but somehow it does. The comedy that's contained is very gentle and is smoothly integrated into the tense atmosphere of TLV. A lot of that comedy is found in the characters Charters and Caldicott who are played by Basil Radford and Naunton Wayne respectively. The two are cricket afficiendos and somehow became a huge sensation, spawning appearances in additional films, radio shows and TV. The rest of the comedy can be found in the great performance from Michael Redgrave who does a great job alongside Lockwood.

Speaking of Lockwood, Alfred Hitchcock uses her to great effect. As the main character, Iris is strong-willed, adventurous as establish and is easy to have sympathy for. The real intrigue is built up once Miss Froy is gone and no one on the train seems to remember having seen her anywhere. Is Iris crazy or is it one big conspiracy? Everything seemingly becomes a clue and motivations of individual characters are well explained without dawdling. The suspense is palpable til the very end of the film.

It's hard to believe that a movie can be so tense with hardly any music. During crucial scenes there's never any music at all and it's just not needed. The Lady Vanishes feels tense because of the mounting confusion being felt by Iris and the performances of all the actors. Even with the light comedy, The Lady Vanishes is a tightly knit thrill.

Taking place almost entirely on a train, The Lady Vanishes is a great Hitchcockian thriller in the truest sense. How many times do we hear that from thrillers these days anyway? You got to go back to the source to really find them and TLV delivers in every way. Even the comedy which is 76 years old still works. There's an action sequence near the end that looks a tad outdated but that's the only criticism I can really find for the last British production of Alfred Hitchcock. Fifteen years into his craft and soon on his way to Hollywood, Alfred Hitchcock is without a doubt a master of mystery and suspense.

Rating

8/10

9 years 8 months ago