I don't think it should get both the Music AND Musical tag. Seems like movies should get one or the other. This is the only one I noticed in both lists. My vote is definitely for Musical.
I don't think the list should be expanded. The source website is clearly trying to define "The Top 100 Silent Era Films". The bonus lists are clearly labeled "Off the List 101-200" and "Off the List 201-300". Though there are certainly some gems on those lists as well, I think these bonus lists are there mostly to encourage voting on the site.
Comments 1 - 4 of 4
Toplist comment on Silent Era's The Top 300 Silent Era Films
fe2000
The Top 100 has become the Top 300. I guess I got outvoted.Movie comment on Cabaret
fe2000
I don't think it should get both the Music AND Musical tag. Seems like movies should get one or the other. This is the only one I noticed in both lists. My vote is definitely for Musical.Toplist comment on IMDb's 1940s Top 50
fe2000
@oypoodles The Magnificent Ambersons is currently scheduled to air on Turner Classic Movies in April 2011.Toplist comment on Silent Era's The Top 300 Silent Era Films
fe2000
I don't think the list should be expanded. The source website is clearly trying to define "The Top 100 Silent Era Films". The bonus lists are clearly labeled "Off the List 101-200" and "Off the List 201-300". Though there are certainly some gems on those lists as well, I think these bonus lists are there mostly to encourage voting on the site.