Sorry, for me nothing but boring, I hate this moving camera and I don't get the reason, why the camera can't stay calm! And I am not homophobe, really.
Blown away by this film - it might be 3 hours long but it grips you all the way. The actresses are insanely good, it must have been a huge commitment to achieve such realism and intensity - a stunning portrayal of all-consuming love and loss. The best film I've seen this year, no doubt. Only minor criticism would be
the 1st sex scene, which was overlong and veered a bit to close to porn for me
A near-perfect execution of realism, if not for the unrealistic portrayal of Lille, France, in particular its climate. I actually live in Lille, and the city as portrayed in this film is unrecognizable.
That's a superficial critique, however, and I actually do rate this as the best of 2013 from what I've seen so far.
I don't a believe a man can't comment on what a woman would feel or that a woman can't comment on how a man would feel,but is there any reason why the director couldn't have told the same story with a young gay boy/man?Would he have been allowed to shoot similar scenes with young gay men?
Brilliant film, although I was a little disappointed overall.
It captured the reality of love/relationships perfectly, but I found that the sexual scenes got boring quickly, although perhaps that was the point.
Add your comment
Comments 1 - 15 of 27
nicolaskrizan
Stimulating!https://beyond1001movies.wordpress.com/2014/12/01/1171/
andype
Sorry, for me nothing but boring, I hate this moving camera and I don't get the reason, why the camera can't stay calm! And I am not homophobe, really.Sunless
The Le Chagrin et la Pitié of romantic movies.jarudet
So excited to see this!David Giancarlo
The Palme, please!Falkhorn
That moment in the movie when you're trying to hide your boner from your brother, which is during the whole duration of the film.Rascally
Did not live up to the hype unfortunately.kurvduam
(removed by mod: please post in English)punkheart
Amazing!_scylla
it didnt seem like three hours at all, everything just falls into place trough out the movie, very natural and realroyalspikey77
Blown away by this film - it might be 3 hours long but it grips you all the way. The actresses are insanely good, it must have been a huge commitment to achieve such realism and intensity - a stunning portrayal of all-consuming love and loss. The best film I've seen this year, no doubt. Only minor criticism would bedevilsadvocado
A near-perfect execution of realism, if not for the unrealistic portrayal of Lille, France, in particular its climate. I actually live in Lille, and the city as portrayed in this film is unrecognizable.That's a superficial critique, however, and I actually do rate this as the best of 2013 from what I've seen so far.
grapenomad
Excellent movie. RAW emotions, great photography, great acting. Wow.hawkeyevigo
I don't a believe a man can't comment on what a woman would feel or that a woman can't comment on how a man would feel,but is there any reason why the director couldn't have told the same story with a young gay boy/man?Would he have been allowed to shoot similar scenes with young gay men?cjn22
Brilliant film, although I was a little disappointed overall.It captured the reality of love/relationships perfectly, but I found that the sexual scenes got boring quickly, although perhaps that was the point.
Showing items 1 – 15 of 27